fbpx Skip to Main Content

Blog

Movie review: ‘Napoleon’

Is “Napoleon” (Sony) dynamite? The answer might depend on whom you ask.

Viewers out for sweeping spectacle will likely come away from director Ridley Scott’s historical epic satisfied. But those seeking insight into the conquering French emperor’s personality will find there’s a hollow ring to star Joaquin Phoenix’s portrayal of him. Battlefield gore and steamy sex scenes, moreover, make the film’s demanding fare suitable only for the hardiest grown-ups.

As Napoleon’s military and political career advances, he falls for the young widow Josephine de Beauharnais (Vanessa Kirby). Screenwriter David Scarpa’s depiction of their relationship, however, is eccentric. Their dialogue carries undertones of a mutual, sadomasochistic desire for mastery while their physical interaction is better fitted to a barnyard than a marital chamber.

Napoleon, the script would have us believe, was a weirdly awkward character. Phoenix fumes and smolders but also delivers lines so out of place as to provoke laughter. The upshot is an unconvincing portrait, though the sequence devoted to his eventual divorce from Josephine – whom he still loved but who had failed to produce an heir – is poignant.

The climactic Battle of Waterloo is also handled impressively. But what precedes it, while sometimes visually striking, is flawed at a human level. Whether mature moviegoers ultimately reckon the artistic tally in the red or the black, they’ll have to be prepared for the numerous taxing elements included in this polished but often implausible retrospective.

The film contains much bloody violence, several gruesome sights, graphic scenes of marital lovemaking, an adultery theme, partial male nudity, obscene imitations of aberrant acts, at least one use of profanity, a couple of milder oaths and fleeting rough and crude language. The OSV News classification is L — limited adult audience, films whose problematic content many adults would find troubling. The Motion Picture Association rating is R — restricted. Under 17 requires accompanying parent or adult guardian.

—John Mulderig, OSV News

USCCB president calls for continued prayer in world where ‘peace seems so far away’

The president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops Nov. 14 urged his brother bishops and all the Catholic faithful to “continue to pray” when “peace seems so far away” in today’s world.

“Our thoughts readily turn to the Holy Land, sacred to all three monotheistic religions,” Archbishop Timothy P. Broglio of the U.S. Archdiocese of the Military Services said in his presidential address.

“We recognize and defend the right of Israel to exist and to enjoy a place among the nations. At the same time, we know that the Palestinians, who represent the majority of Christians in the Holy Land while still being a minority themselves, have a right to a land that is their own,” he said. “The Holy See has long advocated for that right and we also plead for them.”

Archbishop Broglio noted that organizations such as the Knights and Ladies of the Holy Sepulchre and the Catholic Near East Welfare Association “make concrete our commitment to those who suffer and involve Catholics in our nation in a personal way in the suffering of the Holy Land and among her neighbors.”

Those neighbors include Syria, which he said has been almost “forgotten in the deliberations of the powerful,” and Lebanon, which has long shouldered the burden of millions of refugees, he noted. The archbishop also highlighted the struggle of “our Ukrainian sisters and brothers” against “unjust aggression,” the oppression against the church in Nicaragua and the imprisonment of Bishop Rolando Álvarez there, the “delicate nature” of the Catholic Church’s situation in Myanmar and the ongoing crisis in Haiti.

“Unfortunately, it would be easy to continue with a list of areas of conflict in our world,” he said.

“Certainly, we pray that the Prince of Peace might enlighten those who determine the fate of nations,” he said. Archbishop Broglio reminded the bishops how they prayed for peace at their opening Mass Nov. 13, “and I know that we are ready to advocate for lasting peace.”

He praised the USCCB’s Committee on International Justice and Peace for working “tirelessly … to keep the bishops abreast of the developments in these situations and to encourage, within the limits of what is possible, avenues of dialogue and assistance.”

“As successors of the apostles, we participate in the mandate that Christ gave at the Ascension: ‘Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you,'” he said. “It continues to be a daunting task.”

The archbishop also talked about his time as a delegate to the first session of the Synod on Synodality Oct. 4-29 at the Vatican; the synod’s second session will be next October.

“Different cultures and different perceptions always enrich,” he said. “It is … important to listen to each other. Personally, I saw many old friends and met new ones. I was also painfully reminded of the needs of so many younger churches.”

He also noted that he sees collegiality and “many synodal realities” that exist now in the U.S. church through the deliberations of the USCCB’s various committees and how their members interact for the sake of the wider church and in the work of presbyteral and pastoral councils.

“That is not to say that we do not have to grow and open ourselves to new possibilities, but we recognize and build on what is already present,” he said. “We open our hearts to the action of the Holy Spirit and we listen to that voice.”

He spoke of the National Eucharistic Revival and the U.S. church’s effort “to call our daughters and sons home to the fullness of life in Christ in the sacraments,” and praised other initiatives with this as their goal, including the Fellowship of Catholic University Students, NET Ministries, Cursillo and so many others.

“On behalf of all the bishops, I thank those who strive to instill vibrancy, commitment and renewal into our faith communities while reaching out to the peripheries at the same time,” he said.

“On the front lines of these efforts are our committed priests on fire with the Gospel,” he said. “They are our first collaborators and we are so dependent on their tireless efforts.” The archbishop said he is encouraged by “young men preparing in the seminaries” for the priesthood, calling them “a sign of hope for the future.”

“We are unified in our commitment to Jesus Christ and his Gospel,” he told his brother bishops. “We may approach the mission in different ways, but we are convinced that our mandate is to bring everyone to an experience of Jesus Christ who leaves no one indifferent or the same.”

He said he hoped the bishops’ plenary assembly, with its full agenda and opportunities “for fraternal exchanges,” would “enrich each of us and send us home with renewed zeal for the mission we have in common.”

The USCCB president encouraged them to return “emboldened” by the zeal of St. Frances Xavier Cabrini, the first U.S. canonized saint known for her care of the poor, marginalized populations and immigrants, who “never really let anything stop her.” Archbishop Broglio concluded his address with a reference to the Book of Revelation, “Whoever has ears ought to hear what the Spirit says to the churches.”

—Julie Asher and Peter Jesserer Smith, OSV News

Polish museum on World War II veterans tortured, killed by communists is ‘place of prayer’

On Warsaw’s Rakowiecka Street, flanked by a smart new Metro station and office buildings, a gray cement wall runs mournfully along a damp surface of fallen leaves.

At midpoint in the wall, a narrow gateway opens out onto crumbling barrack buildings, still daubed with political graffiti between tightly barred windows.

When Mokotow prison was opened as the Museum of Cursed Soldiers and Political Prisoners of the Polish People’s Republic in March, six years after shedding its last inmates, it was agreed regular Masses and liturgies should be held to dispel the site’s dark, malevolent associations.

Today, dedicated to communist-era resistance fighters and political prisoners, the museum’s melancholy courtyards and corridors gain special poignancy during the commemorative month of November.

“Though this is a secular institution, it’s also a place of prayer,” explained Father Tomasz Trzaska, the museum’s chaplain.

“While Poles place candles each year on the graves of loved ones, we should remember many victims of past misrule have no known resting place. It’s especially those people we pray for in November, as work continues to uncover and identify their remains,” the priest said.

Opened in 1902 by Poland’s Russian occupiers, with room for 800 inmates, Mokotow prison was used during World War II by the Germans, who crammed in more than 2,500 and conducted mass shootings here.

When the war ended, the prison was commandeered by Poland’s new communist Security Ministry, whose officials also secretly eliminated hundreds of internees, in circumstances revealed only in the 1990s.

Prominent victims included Witold Pilecki (1901-1948), a hero of Poland’s underground Home Army, the as AK, who circulated vital reports from Auschwitz-Birkenau after infiltrating the Nazi death camp, and wartime Gen. August Emil Fieldorf, who was hanged here after spurning collaboration.

But the Catholic clergy suffered in the prison as well.

Bishop Antoni Baraniak (1904-1977) had his nails ripped out while refusing to testify against Poland’s primate, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski, while Bishop Czeslaw Kaczmarek of Kielce (1895-1963) endured three years of torture before being sentenced for alleged espionage. Although both bishops lived to tell their stories, many clergy did not.

Among others, Father Rudolf Marszalek, a Nazi camp survivor, was hanged here in March 1948, while Father Zygmunt Kaczynski, a former government minister, was murdered at the prison in May 1953.

The decision to open Mokotow as a museum was made in 2016, on the eve of Poland’s Remembrance Day for Cursed Soldiers, now marked on March 1.

The many items displayed in its airless cells and isolation rooms include typewriters and recording devices used by the security police, as well as forlorn letters, leaflets and diaries confiscated from prisoners.

Although prison chaplains were grudgingly allowed in the later stages of communist rule, Bibles and prayer books were usually taken away, while in the harshest post-war Stalinist years, police agents posing as priests attempted to extract information during fake confessions.

Given the horrors perpetrated in the prison, Father Trzaska thinks religious ceremonies are important — especially for ex-inmates who sometimes show up with friends and relatives.

Lidia Ujazdowska, a Warsaw historian, agrees. Although other aspects of modern Polish history are well known, she said, awareness of communist-era repression remains limited.

For Ujazdowska, the floodlit icon of Poland’s fabled Black Madonna now hanging above the prison’s main stairwell, and the rosaries handed out to visitors, testify to an ongoing effort to expunge the prison’s pent-up atmosphere of dread. During Lent, the Way of the Cross is prayed inside the museum walls, remembering unimaginable suffering and torturing experienced by Polish wartime heroes.

“This museum should serve as a visible warning of humanity’s darker side,” Ujazdowska, who collects survivor testimonies, told OSV News.

“But the services and Masses now held here also signal the victory of goodness, bringing a peaceful aura to a place of suffering and death.”

The bullet-holed rear wall where courageous Capt. Pilecki and other prisoners were shot — before being thrown on a pony cart and dumped in unmarked graves — is now decorated with black memorial tablets and flowers in Poland’s red-white colors.

Across the prison, a subterranean corridor leads to the narrow execution chamber where Fieldorf and his comrades were hanged, while up above photos of Mokotow’s grinning executioners are displayed against red lighting.

Krzysztof Bukowski has special reasons for helping preserve the memory of Mokotow’s prisoners.

His father, Edmund Bukowski, a communications expert wounded with the wartime AK, was shot in the prison in April 1950, leaving him effectively orphaned when his mother also was jailed for 15 years.

In December 2012, his father’s remains were identified during exhumation work at a rubbish pit in Warsaw’s Powazki Cemetery.

“As one of the few surviving direct witnesses, I feel a duty to speak about my own sad connections, something I was barred from doing for much of my life,” Bukowski told OSV News.

“When I guide visitors, I feel I’m walking in the footsteps of those who suffered here, sleeping on bare floors and enduring interrogation without respite. It’s also good for me, as a Catholic, to know prayers are recited here for their eternal rest,” he said.

When a Mass “for those with no graves” was celebrated at the prison-turned-museum Nov. 4, accompanied by poetry and music recitals, it was well attended — a sign, Father Trzaska thinks — of the patriotic sentiment still deeply grounded in Polish national life.

“Even today, as many families still seek justice, it’s supremely important that this site of terror at our national capital’s heart has been regained as a place of contemplation,” Father Trzaska told OSV News.

The so-called Cursed Soldiers, often the highest-ranking officers of the underground resistance army of World War II, were doomed by the communist regime that spread false information that they were traitors of the state — all for the reason that the Polish patriots wanted Poland to be free from Soviet influence, which was the case since the end of the war until 1989.

Father Trzaska added that “there’s still a long way to go in coming to terms with this terrible past. But if we fail to honor people who suffered and died for Poland, we’ll be signing up to the narrative of those who once counted on them being forgotten.”

—Jonathan Luxmoore, OSV News

Abbatial Blessing of Mother Benedict McLaughlin takes place in Newport

More than 500 people attended the Nov. 11 Abbatial Blessing at St. Mary Star of the Sea Church in Newport of Mother Benedict McLaughlin, OSB, first abbess of Immaculate Heart of Mary Abbey in Westfield.

More than 40 years after the first American cloistered monastery of the Benedictine Congregation of Solesmes was officially dedicated in Westfield, it was raised to the status of an abbey in June, and Mother Benedict was elected the first abbess.

With an international congregation of nuns, abbesses, abbots, and priests as well as family members and friends of Mother Benedict, Vermont Catholics and others eager to witness the once-in-a-lifetime event, the Saturday morning Mass was celebrated by Right Rev. Dom Geoffroy Kemlin, OSB, abbot president of the Solesmes Congregation from France.

The imposing church that overlooks Lake Memphremagog was a suitable site for the large gathering, hosted by parishioners and Vocationist Father Rijo Johnson, pastor of Mater Dei Parish based in Newport, which includes St. Mary Star of the Sea Church.

“I feel a deep sense of gratitude to our foundresses for bringing the Solesmes tradition of Benedictine contemplative life to the United States and an awareness of the responsibility to hand on the heritage that it has been a privilege to receive,” Mother McLaughlin wrote in an email before the Abbatial Blessing.

During the Mass, which was celebrated in Latin, the abbot president asked the abbess-elect questions about such things as her intention to persevere in her resolve to keep the Rule of St. Benedict and instruct her sisters to do likewise; about her intention to show fidelity, obedience and reverence to the Church and the pope and his successors; and her intent to show obedience to her ordinary in the government of the abbey according to the canonical laws and constitution of the congregation. To all of these and other questions, she replied, “Volo” (I do).

During the Litany of Saints, the abbess-elect prostrated herself in the sanctuary, and the abbot president blessed her. He then presented the abbess with the Rule of St. Benedict and the abbatial insignia (a ring and a crozier).

The newly blessed abbess was greeted by her two assistants and the guest abbesses, and then the nuns of her own community offered their obedience.

Among those that greeted her was Sister Laurence Couture, OSB, the first prioress. “I am very happy; this is a great day,” she said as she waited for the Mass to begin.

She said Mother Benedict “will be very good” as abbess. “She is a good nun and very bright.”

Mother Benedict, 62, was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and earned a bachelor’s degree in Foreign Service from Georgetown University. “I wanted to be a missionary, which is why I studied foreign service, but the Lord had a different idea,” she said in her email.

She worked for seven years as a legal secretary in a large Washington, D.C., law firm to pay her college debt before she could enter the monastery.

“My discernment visit to the [Westfield] monastery coincided with Holy and Easter weeks, and I was captivated by the beauty and power of the liturgy, solemnly celebrated with Gregorian chant and deeply rooted in history,” she explained. “But it was the singing of the psalms — using God’s own word to speak to God — that ultimately drew me to enter.”

She made her final profession in 1995.

“The contemplative life is, by its very nature, a hidden life, so that the nuns can be totally available for God, who loves us and who deserves to be loved above all else in return,” she wrote. “However, there can be a temptation for nuns to think that because their life is hidden with God that they are forgotten by people. The outpouring of kindness and generosity on the part of the diocese, our neighbors, and friends since the announcement of our becoming an abbey, has proven that this is far from the truth. We are immensely grateful.”

Josh Perry, director of the Office of Worship for the Diocese of Burlington, said the work of the abbey goes unseen by most Catholics in the diocese, but the lives of the nuns in the community are a living witness to St. Paul’s command to “pray without ceasing” and St. Benedict’s call to the “work of God” – “ora et labora” (prayer and work).

“The presence of the abbey in Vermont has become an integral part of the identity and mission of our local Church. In one sense, I view the ministry of the sisters (and the other contemplative communities here) as one of the lungs that breathes life into the wider work of our Church, the other lung being the liturgical life in our parishes that nurtures the spiritual life of Catholics who then go out into the world to spread the Good News,” he said. “The nuns of the community support and hold us up in our evangelizing work through their constant and dedicated prayer. The prayer of the contemplative communities in the Church sustain the Church in its ministry to the world.”

He called the Abbatial Blessing an opportunity for the diocesan Church gathered together to publicly join with the nuns in giving thanks to God for their important presence. The presence of abbots and abbesses from the United States, Canada, and abroad and the celebration of the Mass in Latin — is a visible sign of the universality of the Church — made the blessing not only “a celebration of the abbey or even just of our diocese, but a celebration of the entire universal Church,” he said. “It’s an honor and a joy to be a part of that.”

In his homily at the Mass, Father Gabriel O’Donnell, a Dominican priest of the Province of St. Joseph and professor of Spiritual Theology at the Dominican House of Studies in Washington, D.C., said the blessing of an abbess sets her apart from the other nuns as one who must inspire and encourage as well as correct and call to account: “It would be an impossible task were it not for the grace of Christ which makes all things possible when undertaken in His name and for the good of His flock.”

He encouraged her to “cling to Christ” and let Him love her and let that love give her confidence that He will guide her at every moment.

Monks and nuns are always waiting, keeping vigil for the arrival of the Lord. “They greet Him each morning and through the day in the life of worship, in the silence of the monastery, in prayer, and withdrawal from the world. Every aspect of monastic life is ordered to the future,” he said.

The former prioress, in contemplating the joy of the celebration she attended for her new abbess, looked back briefly as she commented, “I never thought (the monastery) would be an abbey. We were just so happy to open the monastery.”

Msgr. John McDermott, apostolic administrator of the Diocese of Burlington, read an apostolic blessing from Pope Francis and offered his own congratulations, best wishes and prayers at the end of the Mass: “It’s a great day for the Abbey of the Immaculate Heart of Mary [and] a wonderful and beautiful day for the Diocese of Burlington.”

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

November saint: St. Frances Xavier Cabrini

For someone who started life in precarious health, St. Frances Xavier Cabrini certainly proved herself to be a powerhouse when it came to the mission she felt called to fulfill.

Maria Francesca Cabrini – her given name – was born two months premature in 1850 in the town of Sant’ Angelo Lodigiano, Lombardy, Italy. The youngest of the family’s 13 children, she and three of her siblings were the only ones to survive past adolescence. As a young girl, she nearly drowned, which lead to a lifelong fear of water; despite that she ended up crossing the Atlantic Ocean nearly 30 times in service of God and her vocation.

Francesca Cabrini was a well-educated young woman, studying at a convent school run by the Daughters of the Sacred Heart. Having achieved high honors and a teaching certificate, Francesca sought admission to the order but was turned down, not once, but twice, because of her frail health. Instead, she went on to teach for six years at the House of Providence Orphanage in Cadagnono, Italy. A local bishop, admiring her zeal, suggested that she found her own religious order and, in 1880, the Missionary Sisters of the Sacred Heart of Jesus was born.

When the orphanage closed, Francesca, who had added Xavier to her name in honor of St. Francis Xavier, went on to establish seven homes and a free school and nursery in her native Italy. However, it had always been her dream to become a missionary and she had set her sights on moving her order to China. When she approached him about it, Pope Leo XIII had another idea; telling her “Not to the East, but the West,” he prevailed on her to journey to America, to minister to the Italian immigrants who were flooding into New York.

Following a harrowing trip across the ocean, Sister Frances Cabrini and six other sisters arrived in the New World in 1889.They did not have an auspicious beginning; the home that was originally set aside for an orphanage turned out to not be available. The local archbishop suggested very forcefully that they turn around and head back to Italy.

That, however, was not Sister Frances Cabrini’s way. The sisters went ahead with their work anyway, and, when necessary, begged for food and supplies door-to-door in the poor Italian neighborhoods of the lower West Side. In time, their tireless work was noted, and the wealthy Countess of Cesnola donated a valuable property near 59th Street to serve as an orphanage and housing for the sisters. They soon increased their presence to two other addresses in New York and subsequently went to Chicago. Mother Cabrini, as she was now known, now found herself and her work in demand throughout North America.

She became a naturalized United States citizen in 1909 and died in one of her own hospitals in Chicago in 1917. Canonized in 1946, she became the first American saint.  Patron of immigrants, her feast day is celebrated Nov. 13.

Sources for this article include:

cabrininationalshrine.org/timeline-and-her-life-s-work

catholic.org/saints/saint.php?saint_id=278

franciscanmedia.org/saint-of-the-day/saint-frances-xavier-cabrini/

Schreck, Alan. “Catholic Church History from A to Z.” Michigan:  Servant Publications, 2002.

 

Vermont Catholic Charities Advent Appeal

The people who walked in darkness have seen a great light; upon those who lived in a land of gloom a light has shone. — Isaiah 9:1

Please consider being the light for Vermonters in need of emergency assistance by making a gift to Vermont Catholic Charities’ annual Advent Appeal. For 29 years, you have answered the call to bring the joy and hope of the Advent season to those in need.

The “Season of Giving” has no bounds for people in need. At Christmastime and throughout the year, it is a daily struggle for many Vermonters to maintain housing, stay warm or feed their families. By giving to the Advent Appeal you help people in crisis, especially the most vulnerable among us — children, struggling parents, the elderly, and those dealing with medical issues.

Help people like Doreen and Sue put food on the table. Doreen is a grandmother who moved in with her daughter, Sue, to help care for her four grandchildren while Sue recovered from an illness. We provided the family with a food card. Doreen stated, “We are grateful for this assistance. After a difficult year, this support will allow us to have a memorable Christmas. God bless you.”

Help parents like Mike and Julie keep the lights on. Mike and Julie are parents of two children. They work full-time but had an unexpected car repair which put them behind on their bills. They faced a utility disconnect notice. We assisted them with the utility bill. They stated, “Your kindness paved a path to safety and peace.”

These are real people, and with your support we can assist people just like them, our neighbors in need. Every gift — whatever the size — makes a difference. Last year, thanks to your generosity, more than 1,300 adults and 900 children received aid through the Advent Appeal and our year-round Emergency Aid Program. Please support this worthy effort by sending a check to Vermont Catholic Charities, 55 Joy Drive,

South Burlington, VT 05403 or giving online at www.vermontcatholic.org/ adventappeal or scanning the QR code above. Your gift helps us continue to be the hands and feet of Christ, showing God’s love in concrete ways.

On behalf of Vermont Catholic Charities and all the Vermonters you will help, thank you. May the peace of the Advent and Christmas seasons be with you and your loved ones.

With gratitude,

Mary Beth Pinard

Executive Director, Vermont Catholic Charities

—Originally published in the Nov. 11-17, 2023, edition of The Inland See